This both are great(please don't vote carbine automatically) G36 fire rate so high it has high scope but the two problems that I'm worried is the recoil and close range fights. G36 has a problem in close range fights when you scope like its scopes so much. Carbine on the other hand when you use scope you wont see what's happening below(1st person) and i can handle its recoil. G36 is good in mid r